Independent Engineering Reports
Leidos Engineering, LLC. (2026, October 19). Independent engineer’s report: Review of Terabase PlantPredict platform (Project No. 362373). Leidos. Available upon request →
Summary
Leidos Engineering — a widely recognized independent engineer for utility-scale PV projects — completed an independent technical review of PlantPredict Version 12, covering its modeling methodologies, workflow, and a side-by-side energy-yield comparison against Leidos’ standard PVsyst Version 8–based workflow.- Found that PlantPredict’s methodologies generally align with established utility-scale PV engineering practices, including transposition, incidence angle modifiers, bifacial performance, single-diode PV conversion, and inverter and AC-system losses.
- Built parallel PlantPredict and PVsyst-based models for three utility-scale projects (50 to 150 MW-AC) spanning crystalline silicon and CdTe, monofacial and bifacial modules, and fixed-tilt and single-axis tracker designs.
- PlantPredict annual energy estimates ranged from 1.20 % below to 0.53 % above the PVsyst-based workflow, with no consistent directional bias — indicating generally close agreement under equivalent inputs and assumptions.
- Outside of shading, individual loss and gain factors were reasonably aligned. The largest differences were in far shading, near shading, and shading electrical effects, which Leidos described as expected given the differing methodologies for horizon effects, 3D geometry, and terrain-aware shading and backtracking.
- Highlighted PlantPredict’s native sub-hourly simulation and its 3D transposition adjustment for uneven terrain, which Leidos described as an advantage over PVsyst’s nominal tracker-orientation approach.
- Found PlantPredict’s shading and simulation workflow substantially faster than PVsyst and the interface generally intuitive and efficient, particularly for weather data import and review.
- Noted limitations: horizon shading in the version reviewed applied to direct-beam irradiance only (Terabase reports an update in a subsequent release, which Leidos did not evaluate); 3D scene and terrain editing tools are more limited than PVsyst’s; and setup can be more cumbersome for large, heterogeneous layouts, including one atypical mixed east/west project Leidos could not model and replaced.
- Concluded that PlantPredict rests on technically sound modeling methodologies, with no technical deficiencies that would preclude its use in lender-facing energy assessments or project financing, and is capable of producing bankable energy assessments when applied with appropriate engineering rigor. Leidos also recommended further validation against measured operating-plant data.
Solphi Engineering PLLC. (2026, June 30). PlantPredict v12 PV simulation software review. Solphi Engineering.
Summary
Solphi Engineering — an independent engineering firm specializing in PV performance modeling — completed an Independent Engineering review of PlantPredict V12, covering Models & Algorithms documentation, modern modeling capabilities (bifacial, complex terrain, sub-hourly simulation, and advanced tracker schedules), and a head-to-head benchmarking study against PVsyst.- Reviewed PlantPredict’s methodology spanning solar position, tracker algorithms (true-tracking, backtracking, terrain-aware backtracking, irradiance optimization, and wind stow), 2D/3D transposition, bifacial, thermal, single-diode, inverter, and AC/DC loss models — finding no material deficiencies and concluding the platform is aligned with industry best practices.
- Endorsed PlantPredict’s Models & Algorithms documentation as clear and comprehensive, and highlighted UI quality-control features (inline warnings, context help, and Prediction Status workflow) as important for reducing user error.
- Benchmarked PlantPredict V12 against PVsyst v8.1 across 20 simulation variants at three sites — Jaén (Spain), Desert Rock (Nevada), and Wellington (Australia) — spanning bifacial cSi and CdTe, fixed-tilt and SAT, spectral correction, horizon shading, DC losses, sub-hourly SURFRAD data, and complex 3D terrain scenes.
- Across all simulations, average absolute differences in inverter output energy were less than 0.5%, with all individual simulations within 1.0% — well within expected modeling uncertainty and consistent with inter-software variation reported in the Sandia / PVPMC Deville et al. blind assessment.
- Confirmed strong sub-hourly agreement using 1-minute SURFRAD data (inverter-output regression R² ≈ 0.9997) and noted PlantPredict’s ability to efficiently simulate a 1 GW+ tracker system with a 3D scene, which was not practical to replicate in PVsyst on the same hardware.
- Concluded that PlantPredict’s API, sub-hourly simulation, and time-series tracker schedules support integration into operational performance-assessment workflows.
ICF Resources, LLC. (2026, May 29). Independent engineer’s report for PlantPredict PV energy modeling platform. ICF. Available upon request →
Summary
ICF — a global management and analytical consulting firm with a dedicated Energy Advisory Services group — completed the first independent engineer review of PlantPredict V12 (Logic Version 12), including the platform’s new site-level 3D scene modeling, terrain-aware backtracking, 3D transposition, bifacial, wind stow, and irradiance-optimization capabilities introduced since the prior 2017 ICF review.- First IE evaluation of PlantPredict’s site-level 3D scene capability — covering terrain-aware backtracking (TABT), the proprietary 3D transposition model, and 3D shade-scene modeling with electrical shading response.
- ICF rated PlantPredict’s 3D scene approach as “reflecting higher-fidelity approaches than is typical in solar industry-accepted PV performance modeling.”
- All 18 major algorithm categories were rated as “meeting expectations” and consistent with industry-accepted PV performance modeling — including solar position, air mass, clear-sky, GHI decomposition, transposition (incl. 3D), rear-side irradiance (bifacial), tracking and backtracking, irradiance optimization, wind stow, far / near / 3D shading, IAM, spectral correction, module cell temperature, single-diode I-V characterization, DC and AC wiring, inverter efficiency, and transformer efficiency.
- ICF performed an independent energy-yield benchmarking study comparing PlantPredict V12 against PVsyst v8.0.15 across 15 sample U.S. projects spanning Hawaii to Maine, 1.1 MW to 235 MW DC, cSi / HJT-cSi / CdTe module technologies, and both fixed-tilt and single-axis-tracker (SAT) configurations.
- The PlantPredict-versus-PVsyst comparison showed a mean energy-yield difference of just −0.16 %, median of 0.01 %, standard deviation of 0.73 %, and 95 % confidence interval of −0.57 % to +0.24 % — statistically indistinguishable from zero, confirming no systematic portfolio-level bias between the two tools.
- The −0.16 % mean delta is comparable in magnitude to the 0.13 % delta reported in the 2015 Passow study, extending PlantPredict’s validation lineage through Logic Version 12.
- PlantPredict’s modern stateless REST API and Python SDK were endorsed as well-suited for automation, large-scale scenario analysis, and integration into custom analytical workflows.
- The platform’s shared libraries, role-based governance, status management, and documentation tools were validated as supporting consistent, collaborative, and well-governed energy modeling across teams.
DNV GL. (2017, May 22). Technology review of First Solar’s PV simulation software PlantPredict (Document No. 10031850-HOU-R-01, Issue C). DNV KEMA Renewables, Inc.
Summary
DNV GL — a globally recognized independent energy advisor — performed a comprehensive technology review of PlantPredict’s platform architecture, model algorithms, and validation methodology.- Reviewed PlantPredict’s implementations of irradiance transposition, near and far shading, module thermal, single-diode, and inverter performance models — concluding that the underlying algorithms are appropriately selected and substantiated.
- Benchmarked PlantPredict’s outputs against PVsyst (the de facto industry-standard tool at the time) and against operational performance data from First Solar’s utility-scale portfolio.
- Confirmed PlantPredict’s alignment with PVsyst for comparable input assumptions and project configurations.
- Concluded that PlantPredict is suitable for bankable, utility-scale PV energy assessments.
ICF Resources, LLC. (2017, May 16). Independent engineer’s report for First Solar PlantPredict PV modeling platform. ICF.
Summary
ICF — a global management and analytical consulting firm with a dedicated Energy Advisory Services group focused on independent engineering and due-diligence — conducted an independent assessment of the PlantPredict platform spanning user interface, model algorithms, reporting capabilities, and revision management.- Reviewed PlantPredict’s user interface, platform hierarchy, model algorithms, reporting and integration capabilities, and revision management practices, finding the platform’s design “straightforward and well documented” and its hierarchy “logical.”
- Independently benchmarked PlantPredict against PVsyst across four geographically diverse theoretical projects spanning CSi and CdTe module technologies and both fixed-tilt and single-axis tracker configurations.
- Confirmed that PlantPredict’s algorithms are appropriately implemented and substantiated for utility-scale PV generation estimates.
- Concluded that PlantPredict produces PV generation estimates with uncertainty comparable to PVsyst and other bankable modeling platforms.
- Endorsed PlantPredict’s resource-center documentation of critical algorithms and source citations as supporting transparency for users and reviewers.
Black & Veatch Management Consulting, LLC. (2017, January 24). PlantPredict independent engineer report (Project No. 193462). Black & Veatch.
Summary
Black & Veatch — a leading global engineering, procurement, and construction (EPC) firm in the energy sector — performed an independent engineer’s review of PlantPredict in the context of utility-scale PV project development and project finance.- Evaluated PlantPredict’s algorithms, validation methodology, and modeling outputs against the requirements of bankable utility-scale PV project finance.
- Reviewed the platform’s suitability for both engineering decision-making and lender / investor due-diligence processes.
- Confirmed PlantPredict’s suitability as a bankable energy assessment tool for utility-scale solar projects.
Leidos Engineering, LLC. (2016, November 17). Review of First Solar’s PlantPredict photovoltaic simulation software: Final report (CM002569). Leidos.
Summary
Leidos Engineering — a widely recognized independent engineer for utility-scale PV projects — completed a review of PlantPredict and its underlying modeling methodology, benchmarking the platform against PVsyst and against operational performance data.- Performed a comprehensive review of PlantPredict’s modeling approach, input/output structure, and underlying algorithms.
- Benchmarked PlantPredict against PVsyst, the de facto industry-standard PV simulation tool at the time.
- Concluded that PlantPredict provides modeling accuracy equivalent to other energy-prediction modeling tools currently used in the industry.
- Verified that PlantPredict’s predictions match operational performance data within the uncertainty expected of bankable simulation tools.
Peer-Reviewed Publications
Deville, L., Anderson, K. S., Sutterlueti, J., Chambers, T. L., De Brabandere, K., Perez Cicala, F., Lopez-Lorente, J., Mirletz, B., Neubert, A., Nikam, M., Oliosi, M., Prilliman, M., Rhee, K., Schnierer, B., Spokes, J., Wittmer, B., & Theristis, M. (2026). Feature review of photovoltaic modeling software utilizing blind performance assessment. Solar Energy, 304, 114207. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.solener.2025.114207
Summary
The first-ever onymous blind modeling comparison, led by Sandia National Laboratories, benchmarked seven commercially used PV software tools — including PlantPredict — against measured performance from lab- and utility-scale fixed-tilt, monofacial systems at sub-hourly time intervals.- PlantPredict was selected as one of seven industry-leading commercial PV modeling tools evaluated, alongside 3E SynaptiQ, PVsyst, RatedPower, SAM, SolarFarmer, and Solargis Evaluate.
- Predictions were submitted directly by the PlantPredict team, ensuring the platform was exercised exactly as intended by its developers.
- PlantPredict demonstrated sub-hourly modeling capability across both lab- and utility-scale benchmarks.
- Across all seven tools, annual energy-yield deviations from the mean were within ±2.5 % at the lab scale and ±6.0 % at the utility scale — placing PlantPredict squarely within the range of the industry’s most established modeling software.
- The paper publishes four side-by-side feature-comparison tables (POA transposition, module temperature, shading, and performance models) intended as a resource to help users select the most suitable software for their application.
Riedel-Lyngskær, N., Berrian, D., Mira, D. A., Aguilar Protti, A., Behrensdorff Poulsen, P., Libal, J., & Vedde, J. (2020). Validation of bifacial photovoltaic simulation software against monitoring data from large-scale single-axis trackers and fixed tilt systems in Denmark. Applied Sciences, 10(23), 8487. https://doi.org/10.3390/app10238487
Summary
Researchers from the Technical University of Denmark, ISC Konstanz, and European Energy A/S validated eight bifacial PV simulation tools — including PlantPredict — against measured data from 26-kWp bifacial arrays within a 420-kWp site in Denmark (55.6° N, 12.1° E).- PlantPredict was one of eight bifacial PV modeling tools included in the validation, spanning commercial, freeware, and open-source categories.
- The study used consistent input parameters and on-site meteorological data (spectrally flat Class A sensors) across all tools to enable a true apples-to-apples comparison.
- State-of-the-art bifacial performance models — including PlantPredict’s — were shown to add only ~0.5 % uncertainty to the overall PV modeling chain.
- For fixed-tilt configurations, 2-D view-factor simulations (PlantPredict’s bifacial approach) agreed with measured monthly bifacial gain to within ±1 %.
- For horizontal single-axis tracker (HSAT) configurations, 2-D view-factor simulations agreed with measured bifacial gain to within approximately ±2 %.
- PlantPredict completed full-year annual simulations in under 10 seconds, comparable to the fastest commercial tools in the study.
Passow, K., Ngan, L., Littmann, B., Lee, M., & Panchula, A. F. (2015). Accuracy of energy assessments in utility scale PV power plant using PlantPredict. In 2015 IEEE 42nd Photovoltaic Specialist Conference (PVSC) (pp. 1–6). IEEE. https://doi.org/10.1109/PVSC.2015.7356172
Summary
Authored by First Solar engineers and presented at the 42nd IEEE Photovoltaic Specialist Conference, this foundational paper validated PlantPredict in two complementary ways: against the industry-standard PVsyst software and against measured operational data from utility-scale PV plants.- Strong agreement with PVsyst: across 51 equivalent simulations, the mean energy-yield difference between PlantPredict and PVsyst was just 0.13 % ± 0.52 % (1-σ).
- Strong agreement with real operating plants: actual-versus-expected analyses across 20 utility-scale systems totaling nearly 1 GWDC of CdTe modules showed PlantPredict under-predicted energy by only 0.41 % ± 2.01 % (1-σ).
- PlantPredict’s Hayes advanced thermal model reduced hourly module temperature RMSE by 43 % compared to standard thermal modeling.
- The paper established the empirical foundation for PlantPredict’s accuracy claims, including documented benchmarks of transposition models (Perez vs. Hay–Davies) and hourly vs. monthly spectral correction.